Realtor Referral ProgramProperties for RentAbout UsContact Us
Firefly Property Management, LLCFirefly Property Management, LLC
    • Best. Residents. Ever.

      Check out our expert property management services in Central Pennsylvania!

    • View All Services
    • Ensure reliable tenants with Firefly Property Management's comprehensive tenant screening services. Our meticulous process includes credit checks, criminal background checks, employment verification, rental history, and reference checks. Protect your investment and find the best tenants today!
      Tenant Screening

      Ensure reliable tenants with Firefly Property Management's comprehensive tenant screening services. Our meticulous process includes credit checks, criminal background checks, employment verification, rental history, and reference checks. Protect your investment and find the best tenants today!

    • Discover top-notch property marketing services with Firefly Property Management. Attract high-quality tenants quickly with our expert marketing strategies, professional photography, targeted advertising, and SEO-optimized listings. Contact us today to fill your vacancies!
      Marketing

      Discover top-notch property marketing services with Firefly Property Management. Attract high-quality tenants quickly with our expert marketing strategies, professional photography, targeted advertising, and SEO-optimized listings. Contact us today to fill your vacancies!

    • Maximize your property's potential with Firefly Property Management's expert rental leasing services. From market analysis and professional marketing to thorough tenant screening and hassle-free lease management, we ensure your rental success. Contact us today to get started!
      Lease Execution & Renewals

      Maximize your property's potential with Firefly Property Management's expert rental leasing services. From market analysis and professional marketing to thorough tenant screening and hassle-free lease management, we ensure your rental success. Contact us today to get started!

    • Ensure timely and reliable rent collection with Firefly Property Management. Our professional services include proactive communication, detailed reporting, and compliance with legal standards, ensuring a stress-free experience for property owners. Contact us today to streamline your rent collection process!
      Rent Collection

      Ensure timely and reliable rent collection with Firefly Property Management. Our professional services include proactive communication, detailed reporting, and compliance with legal standards, ensuring a stress-free experience for property owners. Contact us today to streamline your rent collection process!

    • Ensure your rental property remains in top condition with Firefly Property Management's expert maintenance services. Serving Lancaster PA, York PA and surrounding areas, we offer 24/7 emergency maintenance, routine inspections, preventative care, and more. Contact us today!
      Property Maintenance

      Ensure your rental property remains in top condition with Firefly Property Management's expert maintenance services. Serving Lancaster PA, York PA and surrounding areas, we offer 24/7 emergency maintenance, routine inspections, preventative care, and more. Contact us today!

    • Ensure accurate and transparent financial reporting with Firefly Property Management. Serving Lancaster PA, York PA and surrounding areas, we offer detailed monthly statements, online access, budgeting, forecasting, and tax preparation assistance. Contact us today!
      Financial Reporting

      Ensure accurate and transparent financial reporting with Firefly Property Management. Serving Lancaster PA, York PA and surrounding areas, we offer detailed monthly statements, online access, budgeting, forecasting, and tax preparation assistance. Contact us today!

    • Handle evictions efficiently and legally with Firefly Property Management. Serving the Lancaster and York PA areas, we offer experienced professionals, legal compliance, and post-eviction services. Contact us today for stress-free eviction management!
      Eviction Protection

      Handle evictions efficiently and legally with Firefly Property Management. Serving the Lancaster and York PA areas, we offer experienced professionals, legal compliance, and post-eviction services. Contact us today for stress-free eviction management!

    Areas We Serve
    • Lancaster, PA
    • York, PA
    • Elizabethtown, PA
    • Shiloh, PA
    • Columbia, PA
    • Lititz, PA
    • Willow Street, PA
    • Mechanicsburg, PA
    • Millersville, PA
    • Mount Joy, PA
    • Camp Hill, PA
    • Red Lion, PA
    • New Holland, PA
    • Manheim, PA
    • Manchester, PA
    • Dover, PA
    • Ronks, PA
    • Owner Portal

      A Dashboard for property owners to easily view analytics, financial reporting and more.

    • FAQ's

      Our ever-growing list of owner-related frequently asked questions with answers!

    • Tenant Portal

      A Dashboard for residents to pay rent, make maintenance requests and easily get in touch with us.

    • FAQ's

      Our ever-growing list of resident oriented frequently asked questions with answers!

    • Move Out Instructions

      Simple moving instructions for residents.

    • Wrap up the year with a comprehensive rental property review! Discover essential tips for preparing financial records, evaluating property performance, and maximizing tax deductions. Partner with Firefly Property Management to simplify year-end tasks and set your investments up for success.
      End-of-Year Rental Property Assessment: A Comprehensive Guide for Property Owners

      As the year wraps up, it’s the perfect opportunity for landlords to review their rental properties’ performance and gear up for the year ahead. An end

    • Get your home winter-ready in Lancaster, York, and Central PA with these expert tips. Learn how to protect your property and discover how Firefly Property Management can help you ensure peace of mind all winter long!
      Preparing Your Home For Winter in Central PA

      Winter in Central Pennsylvania, including Lancaster and York, brings beautiful snowy landscapes but also challenging weather conditions that can impac

    • Get your home fall-ready with our step-by-step guide! Learn how to prepare your property for cooler weather with tips on gutter cleaning, sealing windows, and more. Perfect for homeowners and those managing investment properties in York, Lancaster, and Central PA.
      A Beginner’s Guide to Preparing Your Pennsylvania Home for Fall

      As summer winds down and the cool breezes of fall begin to make their presence felt, it’s time to prepare your home for the seasonal shift. For homeow

    • Discover why Firefly Property Management stands out as the best property management company in Pennsylvania. From tenant screening to local market expertise, learn how Firefly maximizes your rental property’s success in Lancaster and York, PA.
      8 Reasons Why Firefly Property Management Is the Best Property Management Company in PA

      If you’re a property owner or investor in Pennsylvania, finding a reliable and effective property management company can make all the difference in th

    • Discover why renting your home in York and Lancaster, PA, is a lucrative option. Learn about the benefits of renting, including steady income, tax advantages, and market stability with Firefly Property Management.
      Renting Vs Selling

      Why It's an Excellent Time to Rent Your Home in York, PA, and Lancaster, PA As property owners in the vibrant communities of York, PA, and Lancaster,

    •  Learn how real estate investors in Lancaster, PA can defer taxes and grow their portfolios with a 1031 exchange. Discover the process, key timelines, and benefits in our comprehensive guide.
      Maximize Your Investment with a 1031 Exchange in Lancaster, PA

      Are you a real estate investor in Lancaster, PA, considering selling an investment property? If so, leveraging a 1031 exchange can help you defer taxe

    More from our blog
Telephone
+1 (717) 403-7117
Call or Text us now →
Best. Residents. Ever.  Read more →

Property Management 

You hand us the keys, we'll handle the rest

Telephone
+1 (717) 403-7117
Call or Text us now →

Trusted by thousands of clients

Stress free, expert property management in Lancaster PA, York PA and surrounding areas

Years in Business
22
Client Satisfaction
98.5%
Eviction Rate
< 1%
Response Time
15 minutes
Days on Market
< 2 weeks

The all-in-one solution

Discover Our Services

Do you own a rental property in Central PA? Are you tired of the toilets, tenants, and troubles that come with it? We’re Firefly Property Management, your professional landlords. We’ll manage the day-to-day operations of your rental property, and take the stress out of owning a rental.

Whether you have one property or one hundred, Firefly Property Management can help save you money and time so you can build income, not be a landlord. We invest in the hours, care, and skill it takes to manage properties and maximize returns so you can spend your precious time on what matters most to you. Trust our team with your investment.

Property Marketing
Say goodbye to long vacancy periods with our cutting-edge marketing on your side. We use a combination of proven promotional tools to reach a large local audience.
Tenant Screening
Start your lease off on the right foot and keep yourself protected with our in-depth tenant screening process. We perform a rigorous screening to ensure we place the best tenant possible.
Rent Collection
Receive your rent payments without a second thought. We handle invoicing and rent collection. We handle all of your rental's accounting needs.
Maintenance
Stop wasting your downtime handling a long list of maintenance tasks. We process repair requests, dispatch workers, and ensure the work is done correctly.
Property Evaluations
Our team conducts frequent walkthroughs of each property. We use these visits to check for lease compliance issues and check on the condition of the property.
Financial Reporting
Every month, our team compiles detailed financial reports for your review. Quickly determine your recent expenses and earnings and gauge your home's current performance.

Best. Residents. Ever.

Connect with our expert property management team today!

100% Customer Satisfaction Guaranteed

Everything you need as a landlord

Get great property management, protected by our guarantees.

30 day Risk Free Guarantee

Our team will lease your quality home fast to a highly qualified renter "at market rent" for your investment in 30 days or less or receive 1 month of free management. We work diligently to protect your cash flow.

Satisfaction Guaranteed

Unhappy with our service? We don't lock you into a long term contract. Walk away at any time without paying a penalty.

0.5% Eviction Rate

Most investors would say that having to evict a tenant is the worst possible scenario for a rental property owner. With our tenant screening process and high qualification standards, we have maintained an eviction rate of less than 1% each year.

Our values

Simply put, We treat your investment like our own.

Integrity
We are committed to integrity and professionalism in everything we do. Our dedication to ethical business practices and superior customer service sets us apart in the industry.
Transparency
Transparency and communication are the cornerstones of our approach. We believe in fostering strong, trusting relationships with our clients by keeping them informed every step of the way.
Accountability
We take ownership of our actions and decisions. We hold ourselves accountable for delivering results, meeting commitments, and fulfilling obligations to our clients, tenants, and vendors.
Excellence
We are dedicated to delivering excellence in every aspect of our service. From property advertising, leasing, screening and maintenance to tenant and owner relations, we set high standards for ourselves and continuously seek ways to exceed expectations.
Collaboration
We believe in the power of teamwork and collaboration. By fostering a culture of respect, communication, and collaboration, we leverage the diverse talents and perspectives of our team to achieve common goals and drive success.
Continuous Improvement
We are dedicated to ongoing learning and improvement. Through regular evaluation, feedback, and adaptation, we strive to learn from our experiences, refine our processes, and continually raise the bar for excellence.
Professional and Personal Growth
We provide an environment that nurtures both personal and professional growth, empowering our employees to reach their full potential and achieve their career aspirations.

See what our customers are saying

We have worked with thousands of amazing clients

“After meeting Sarah on a few occasions now, it’s certainly not hard to see that she’s an expert in the field of real estate. Both Darren and myself work with several brokers in the United States, New Zealand, and Australia, and can see that Sarah with her systems, organization skills, and knowledge for growth is fantastic. Her knowledge and history of works in the US speaks for itself, and once you spend some time with her, you’ll understand and see why she’s had so much success. Being trainers from Australia we certainly appreciate meeting and spending time with Sarah whenever we can.”

Darren Hunter and Dinez Yusuf
International Board of Certified Trainers

“Working with Firefly has been an amazing experience for us. Our last management company would rarely if ever answer the phone, and it took days to get a response from email, if we ever got a response at all. Our previous tenants left the house a mess and we were not even informed. Thankfully Firefly was able to get someone out to our property the following day to get cleaning and repairs in order, and had new tenants within a couple of weeks. We have been blown away by the level of service. Thank you!”

Chad J

“Easy to rent from, easy lease signing process, and fast to respond. We did have an issue with the garbage disposal going out within the first few days of moving in, but they got someone out by the next day and had it replaced. So far so good.”

Jerome P

“Sarah has been so great to work with. When my husband's work required us to relocate we knew we did not want to sell our home, but we did not really know what to do. After speaking with Sarah she put so many of my concerns at ease. I did not know the first thing about being a landlord, and thanks to Sarah and Firefly I don't have to. They had our property rented faster than we could have anticipated. Thank you!”

Amanda B

“We have been looking for a rental property for a while, and were either just missing homes for rent, or were not getting responses from owners or management companies. After speaking with Firefly I gave them some ideas of what I was looking for and 3 weeks later we were moving into a property the day it came on the market. 5 star service all around.”

Shawn R

Owner frequently asked questions

Have a different question and can’t find the answer you’re looking for? Reach out to our support team by giving us a call and we’ll get back to you as soon as we can.

Tenant frequently asked questions

Have a different question and can’t find the answer you’re looking for? Reach out to our support team by giving us a call and we’ll get back to you as soon as we can.

Contact Firefly Property Management Today

As the premier property management company in Central Pennsylvania, we understand the importance of effective communication and personalized assistance when it comes to managing your rental property or addressing any concerns you may have.

At Firefly Property Management, we pride ourselves in keeping our clients completely satisfied with our service, which means quick responses. No matter the circumstances, we're here for you. That's what makes Firefly Property Management Pennsylvania's trusted property management firm. Contact us today and let us know how we can help you with your needs!

Address
313 West Liberty Street
Suite 260
Lancaster, PA 17603
Telephone
+1 (717) 403-7117
Call or Text us now →
Email
office@fireflypm.com
Google Maps Business Location

Free Management Quote

Are you ready to give us the hassle and headache of managing your own property?

  • Find out what your property should rent for. We utilize industry best practices, up to the minute expertise and state of the art technology to bring you the most accurate plan for your investment.
  • Learn why we are the trusted choice in Central PA
  • Enjoy more freedom & peace of mind

Property Information

Tell us about the property address you would like to have under management

Areas We Serve

  • Lancaster
  • York
  • Elizabethtown
  • Shiloh
  • Columbia
  • Lititz
  • Willow Street
  • Mechanicsburg
  • Millersville
  • Mount Joy
  • Camp Hill
  • Red Lion
  • New Holland
  • Manheim
  • Manchester
  • Dover
  • Ronks

Footer

Firefly Property Management, LLCFirefly Property Management, LLC
Address
313 West Liberty Street
Suite 260
Lancaster, PA 17603
Telephone
+1 (717) 403-7117
Call or Text us now →
Email
office@fireflypm.com
FacebookInstagramLinkedinYouTube

Property Management

  • Services
  • Areas We Serve

Company

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Blog
  • Properties for Rent
  • Realtor Referral Program
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Sitemap

Owners

  • FAQ
  • Owner Portal

Tenants

  • FAQ
  • Tenant Portal

© 2025 Firefly Property Management, LLC. All rights reserved.